I did not enter into reading Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights with high expectations. In fact, I entered that particular reading with expectations set well below my normal level of tolerance, and only chose to read it out of necessity, as it was the only book in my possession in between library trips. I had expected a book with a flimsy, romantic plot held together by a smattering of intolerably corny characters. Wuthering Heights is not the book that I had expected. There is no way to fall in love with Emily Bronte’s characters; even those that appear to be archetypal individuals quickly take on extreme personalities and, in most cases, some degrees of ugliness. Those elements that grant the book great story-telling are the bizarre selection of characters, and the disarmingly unpredictable plot.
Although Bronte’s settings include none of the extraordinary situations or true external interventions that drive some other books, Wuthering Heights still has an unmistakable line of plot through feeding off of the characters and personalities instead. Bronte is able to create painfully unusual characters that break from the reader’s expectations—namely Heathcliff and Catherine Earnshaw. Where a modern reader might expect to find a tale of the underdog following Heathcliff’s introduction into the plot, this is quickly abandoned by revealing the manipulative nature of all the characters. His actions are obsessive to a point of insane, which is only magnified by his ugly personality, the center of Bronte’s tale. While there is no fantastical world that could swallow the reader in intricacy and detail, Bronte has no need of alien settings or disturbing environments in her novel, all of the conflict possibly needed is easily provided by her unsettling human creations.
However, Bronte’s novel follows the mode of story-telling a wee bit too closely, especially when considering the role of the irrelevant narrator. Serving only to introduce the reader to the dark enigma that is Heathcliff, and as an excuse to check in with the second generation of characters down the road, the character of Mr. Lockwood is ultimately of little consequence in any part of the story. Other than the means by which to introduce the actual plot, his character is distracting from the actual story. Although it could be argued that he serves as a window into Wuthering Heights from an outsider’s eyes, just as much could be accomplished with a less cumbersome means of storytelling.